The Coaster
Monday, September 25, 2023
No Result
View All Result
  • Browse News by Town
    • Allenhurst
    • Asbury Park
    • Avon
    • Bradley Beach
    • Deal
    • Interlaken
    • Loch Arbour
    • Long Branch
    • Neptune
    • Neptune City
    • Ocean Grove
    • Ocean Township
    • Tinton Falls
  • e-Edition
    • Read Now
    • Subscribe to e-Edition
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
Subscribe / Renew
  • Browse News by Town
    • Allenhurst
    • Asbury Park
    • Avon
    • Bradley Beach
    • Deal
    • Interlaken
    • Loch Arbour
    • Long Branch
    • Neptune
    • Neptune City
    • Ocean Grove
    • Ocean Township
    • Tinton Falls
  • e-Edition
    • Read Now
    • Subscribe to e-Edition
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
The Coaster
No Result
View All Result
Home Asbury Park

Holy Spirit Church Lawsuit Scheduled For Court March 17

by Carol Gorga Williams
March 14, 2023
in Asbury Park
Demolition of Holy Spirit Church Sought
1.4k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare via EmailShare on Twitter

By CAROL GORGA WILLIAMS

While Asbury Park officials and the proposed developer of the Holy Spirit property were due back in court last week to approve the developer’s six-lot subdivision, those negotiations are on hold after Thomas De Seno brought a series of motions to challenge the church’s sale to the developer.

The case is scheduled to be heard in Freehold March 17.

De Seno is seeking a temporary restraining order to delay any development at the property on Second Avenue. He named the diocese of Trenton, the diocese, the local pastor of  Mother of Mercy – which is the consolidated parish necessitated by the closure of Holy Spirit – and Bishop David O’ Connell all of various misdeeds that damaged the longevity of Holy Spirit.

The history of the demolition of the church began several years ago when the diocese announced it was closing the church because of declining attendance and the increasing expense of maintaining the site. The purchase price was to go to repair and maintenance at the former Our Lady of Mount Carmel church and parochial school.The diocese desanctified the church and listed the Second Avenue site  for $2.75 milli0on property but ultimately sold it for much less because of damages to the church incurred  by workers sent from St. Dominic’s in Brick which received numerous artifacts. .

This week, De Seno asked Monmouth County Assignment Court Judge Lisa P. Thorton to disqualify the law firm represented by the city because of a potential conflict with the developer. De Seno says the law firm of Cleary, Giacobbe, Alfieri and Jacobs should be disqualified because it had represented Joseph Hanna of JLD Investments, who is a developer of the site.

“The most salient fact to keep in mind in the case at bar is that the Cleary firm’s prior representation was not of JDL Investors Group, LLC, which itself has limited or no interest in the other personal holdings of Joseph Hanna,” according to De Seno’s certification. “Rather, it is Cleary’s representation of Joseph Hanna individually that gives rise to the conflict because Cleary can never harm any of Hanna’s interests, and his interests substantially include the business success of Plaintiff JLD. The Cleary firm, by representing Asbury Park, is called upon to oppose that interest in this very case.”

Mayor John B. Moor declined comment but noted that the law firm was appointed by the Joint Insurance Firm of which the city is a participant.

The six-lot subdivision initially rejected by the city put a lot of power into the hands of the  developer because the plan was a conforming one based on the requirements of the city’s zoning code. Lawyers advising the city thought the city had no grounds to prevail at trial.

But De Seno disagrees.

“I think we have a very strong case,” said De Seno opposing the city’s rejection of the plan as ” legally “indefensible.”

Moor has been cast the villain by those who support the developer and recently said a few words in defense of the city’s position even though people involved in lawsuits do not  typically make public statements outside the courtroom. He said he expected to be “scolded’ for his statements.

“We did not apply to knock down the church,” Moor said.

  De Seno is proceeding as well against the diocese although a diocese spokeswoman said the diocese stepped away from the negotiations.

Related Posts

2 Teens Charged in Asbury Park Fatal Shooting

2 Teens Charged in Asbury Park Fatal Shooting

September 22, 2023
Wellness Garden Opened by County Boys and Girls Club in Asbury Park

Wellness Garden Opened by County Boys and Girls Club in Asbury Park

September 20, 2023

Sea.Hear. Now Festival

September 20, 2023

Sea.Hear. Now Festival

September 20, 2023
Asbury Park’s Grand Hotels and Evolution of Early Black Music

Asbury Park’s Grand Hotels and Evolution of Early Black Music

September 20, 2023
Movies Return to The ShowRoom Oct. 29

LGBTQ Film Fest at Showroom

September 19, 2023

Trending This Week

2 Teens Charged in Asbury Park Fatal Shooting

2 Teens Charged in Asbury Park Fatal Shooting

September 22, 2023
Asbury Park’s Grand Hotels and Evolution of Early Black Music

Asbury Park’s Grand Hotels and Evolution of Early Black Music

September 20, 2023
Allenhurst Police Blotter

Allenhurst Police Blotter

September 20, 2023
Sea. Hear. Now Festival

Sea. Hear. Now Festival

September 20, 2023

Advertise Online with The Coaster

Advertise on The Coaster to reach countless new customers for your local business.

START ADVERTISING TODAY

E-mail Newsletter

Sign up to get a free weekly newsletter to your inbox.

Subscribe

Contact Us

The Coaster
1011 Main St
Asbury Park, NJ 07712
Phone: 732-775-3010
FAX: 732-775-8345
editor@thecoaster.net

Email Newsletter »

All Articles

  • 2023 Articles
  • 2022 Articles

e-Edition

  • All e-Editions
  • Subscribe to e-Edition

Search Our Site

No Result
View All Result

Edit Account
Logout

© 2023 The New Coaster, LLC. All rights reserved. • Privacy Policy

No Result
View All Result
  • Browse News by Town
    • Allenhurst
    • Asbury Park
    • Avon
    • Bradley Beach
    • Deal
    • Interlaken
    • Loch Arbour
    • Long Branch
    • Neptune
    • Neptune City
    • Ocean Grove
    • Ocean Township
    • Tinton Falls
  • e-Edition
    • Read Now
    • Subscribe to e-Edition
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
Subscribe / Renew

© 2023 The New Coaster, LLC. All rights reserved. • Privacy Policy